Documentation of the Summer School “Doing Qualitative Education Research in/of/through Algorithmic Environments”

HSU

5. October 2023

From September 18 to 20, the Chair of Transformation of Governance in Education and Society hosted a 3-day international summer school at Helmut Schmidt University. The aim of the event was to introduce young researchers to different methodological perspectives on how qualitative educational research can address increasingly datafied and algorithmized environments and make them both the object and the tool of their research. For that, 26 participants from more than 10 different countries had the opportunity to attend various inputs and to engage in conversation with each other.

Please find more information on the event here.

Summer School: Doing Qualitative Education Research in/of/through Algorithmic Environments

HSU

10. January 2023

Prof Dr Sigrid Hartong and M.A. Nina Brandau are organising a summer school at the HSU Hamburg, which will take place from September 18-20, 2023. The summer school offers a forum for emerging scholars (PhD students and Postdocs) to systematically engage with different methods of qualitative research in/of/through algorithmic environments. Besides input on different research methods from six well-known international experts from Australia, Belgium, Denmark, Finland and Germany, participants will have the opportunity for individual conversations with the experts and exchange and networking with their peers.

Application is open until March 15, 2023 and all information can be found in this call.

New special issue published: “Space- and time-making in education: Towards a topological lens”

HSU

31. October 2022

Together with Mathias Decuypere and Karmijn van de Oudeweetering, Prof. Dr. Sigrid Hartong published a special issue of the European Educational Research Journal. The issue called “Space- and time-making in education: Towards a topological lens” is concerned with the research approach of (social) topology. This approach has its origins in the field of mathematics, but has been increasingly applied to social and educational research. (Social) topology is particularly fruitful to investigate the (mutual) construction of space and time.

The special issue is available via this link.

Workshop “PREGOV III – Towards Transdisciplinary Perspectives on Algorithmic Prediction & Decision-Making”

HSU

15. August 2022

On September 15 and 16, 2022, the workshop „PREGOV III (PREdictive GOVernance) – Towards Transdisciplinary Perspectives on Algorithmic Prediction & Decision-Making” is taking place for the third time as part of an international workshop series focusing on predictive governance. The main topics addressed at this year’s workshop are:
1.) Organizational-theoretical perspectives on the topic of predictive governance,
2.) different types of use of algorithmic prediction and decision-making in organizations and,
3.) possibilities, limits, and challenges of specific research methods.
The three panels during the workshop will focus on organizations from the public sector (panel 1), the cooperate sector (panel 2) and the educational sector (panel 3).

The workshop will take place at Pop-up-Horst Hamburg (Winterhuder Weg 112, 22085 Hamburg). Registration is still possible. Please contact Dr. Manuel Reinhard (member of the organizational committee) via email: [email protected]

Abstract Workshop

The datafication of the future has significant consequences for contemporary and upcoming policies in different sectors of society as well as for their analysis. The latter implies the need for theoretical reflection and methodological innovations, especially for new types of data that
become accessible to empirical research. This development should be understood as both a challenge and an opportunity for further analytical developments. How does the datafication of the future change future policies – collective practices of imagining, planning, and controlling
future(s) – in different sectors of a society? What influence does it have on the rationalities and normativities in specific organizations? What demands do research methods have to meet in order to be able to answer these questions?

Against this backdrop, this year’s PREGOV-workshop focuses on organizational and methodological questions in practices of predictive governance. Building on our previous meetings, our aim is to explore what insights organizational-theoretical perspectives promise, what
uses of algorithmic prediction need to be distinguished in different organizational settings, and which research methods allow us to learn about them.

The workshop will bring together established and young scholars from Germany and abroad from diverse fields such as philosophy, sociology, and economics, organization and educational science to find preliminary answers to these questions. Thematically, we will focus on the following topics: (1) Organizational-theoretical perspectives on the topic of predictive governance, (2) different types of use of algorithmic prediction and decision-making in organizations and, hence, (3) possibilities, limits, and challenges of specific research methods. Our aim is to foster a discussion on fundamental organizational-theoretical, methodological, and empirical questions of research on predictive governance in the different fields of public administration, education and business, thereby creating transdisciplinary learning opportunities for the future research of all workshop participants.

Download Symbol-Icon
Program PreGov Workshop 2022

International Workshop “Unpacking the ‘In-Between’”

HSU

24. January 2022

This week, Prof. Dr. Sigrid Hartong, Dr. Karola Cafantaris, Annina Förschler and Nina Brandau are participating in the international workshop “Unpacking the ‘In-Between’”. The workshop was organised by Prof. Geiss and Prof. Röhl (University Zürich) and Prof. Hartong.

The workshop focuses on the so-called “Intermediaries in the Digital Transformation of Schooling”, a topic that Sigrid Hartong and Annina Förschler have already contributed in the past. After the event, we will provide a short video summary and the presented slides on this website.

Abstract Workshop

Despite a rising body of research on the digital transformation of schooling, public discourse often still conceive of the integration of educational technologies into classrooms as a straightforward or linear process. However, such a perspective neglects the large variety of mediators or intermediaries involved in this process, including their important roles in shaping how digital approaches manifest themselves in classroom settings (Williamson 2015, Hartong 2016). Such intermediaries include human actors, among them technology providers or EdTech brokers (e.g., Beer 2017, Williamson 2016), as well as non-human actors such as digital/data infrastructures, platforms, documents or sites (e.g., Sellar 2015, Decuypere et al. 2021, Selwyn 2014, Gulson/Witzenberger 2020).

Even though the scholarly attention for the ‘in-betweens’ of digital education is growing, the function of intermediaries as an interrelated, continuously transforming field of its own still remains to be mapped. With this workshop, we want to address this gap by bringing together cutting-edge European researchers– qualitatively and quantitatively oriented, present-day and historically oriented –, exploring how digital technologies are ‘brought into’ schools. We invite scholars with different approaches and perspectives on intermediaries to participate in this workshop. Further, we are interested in contributions that focus not only on the classroom level and/or on the digital transformation of teaching practices, but also on the broader environment of digital schooling. This includes, for example, technology used in children ́s homes. Another example is school technology used for communicating with parents or for administrative reasons, including the preparation of lessons, the creation of assignments and schedules, registration, or reporting. Finally, providers of educational technology use various ‘intermediary sites’ (e.g. trade shows) to advertise their products and recruit potential schools as customers. Indeed, we argue that such a variety of approaches is needed to understand both the multidimensionality and the common logics of the ‘in-between’ in the digital transformation of schooling.

Interesting articles by the professorship on the topic:

Hartong, Sigrid (2016) Between assessments, digital technologies, and big data: the growing influence of ‘hidden’ data mediators in education. In: Martens, Kerstin; Niemann, Dennis & Teltemann, Janna (Hrsg.) European Educational Research Journal, Special Issue: Effects of International Assessments in Education – A Multidisciplinary Review, 15(5): 523-536. Link.

Förschler, Annina (2021) Der wachsende politische Einfluss privater (EdTech-)Akteure im Kontext digitaler Bildungsbeobachtung und -steuerung: Bemühungen um ein ‚dateninfrastrukturfreundliches Ökosystem‘. In: Bildung unter (digitaler) Beobachtung – Analysen zur wachsenden Bedeutung von Dateninfrastrukturen in der Bildungssteuerung. Thementeil in der Zeitschrift für Pädagogik, 67(3): 323-337. Link.

Förschler, Annina (2018) Das ‚Who is who?‘ der deutschen Bildungs-Digitalisierungsagenda – eine kritische Politiknetzwerk-Analyse. In: Pädagogische Korrespondenz, 58(2): 31-52. Link.

Hartong, Sigrid & Förschler, Annina (2020) The rising power of business interests through intermediary policy networking: insights into the ‘digital agenda’ in German schooling. Link.

PREGOV II – „Towards Transdisciplinary Perspectives on Algorithmic Prediction & Decision-Making“ Workshop

HSU

13. September 2021

Building on our first meeting in 2020, we are happy to announce that a second workshop will take place next week, September 17 and 18, 2021.

The upcoming PreGov II workshop continues to explore the increasing digitalization of public governance and how new forms of datafication, quantification, and automation enable governments and other powerful stakeholders to construct images of the future. We inquire how human and machine-made (or assisted) decisions intertwine. In terms of the notions of governing and governance, the question arises as to who (or what) actually governs or regulates whom (or what).

If you are interested to join in, please send an email to [email protected].

Here you can find the PDF with all the informations on the workshop, updates will be posted at ResearchGate and at www.hsu-hh.de/icu/pregov2.

New Chapter in Book: Unblack the Box. Anregungen für eine (selbst)bewusste Auseinandersetzung mit digitaler Bildung

HSU

26. July 2021

For the new (German) book by Ralf Lankau “Autonom und mündig am Touchscreen. Für eine konstruktive Medienarbeit in der Schule” the initiative UNBLACK THE BOX contributed a chapter. You can find a part of the book and a list of all chapters on the publishers page for free. If you have any questions, please don’t hesitate to contact us.

Hartong, Sigrid; Allert, Heidrun; Amos, Karin; Bleckmann, Paula; Czarnojan, Izabela; Förschler, Annina; Jornitz, Sieglinde; Reinhard, Manuel & Sander, Ina (2021) Unblack the Box. Anregungen für eine (selbst)bewusste Auseinandersetzung mit digitaler Bildung. In: Lankau, Ralf (Hrsg.) Autonom und mündig am Touchscreen. Für eine konstruktive Medienarbeit in der Schule. Beltz Verlag: Weinheim/Basel: 201-212.

Transnational perspectives on schooling in the pandemic – Online dossier by the Heinrich-Böll-Foundation

HSU

27. May 2021

In its dossier “Digital School: Lessons from the Pandemic”, the Heinrich Böll Foundation brings together transatlantic experts to discuss and share their perspectives on the effects of the recent pandemic on schooling. With her contribution “Quality, not speed, is what we need” Sigrid Hartong argues for a sustainable, pedagogically and socially oriented digitalization. Link.

Keynotes online! International Workshop “Building Data Literacy with the Teaching Profession at Global Scale”

HSU

18. May 2021

On March 18th 2021, the Education and Social Research Institute (ESRI) at Manchester Metropolitan University and the Research Lab on Digital Education Governance at Helmut-Schmidt-Universität (HSU) in Hamburg hosted an exciting online event to explore strategies for building data literacy with the teaching profession at global scale.
A workshop report, the recorded keynote presentations as well as the abstracts of all participants are available online now.